Right Brain Lefty

My left hand and right brain meet here.

Sep 9, 2009 10:04am

About tumblarity

From UI-patterns.com:

A common feature on many websites letting users contribute content is a list of the most interesting content on the website right now. It is often presented as highest rated content, most read content, or just most popular content (whatever that is…).

Is the rating or the view count really the best way of finding out what is more popular – or even more important: what is more interesting?

The fallacy of the most read criteria as an indicator for interestingness is its re-enforcing effect. Once something has reached most read status it will be highlighted and thus be read even more – making it harder for actual more interesting content to emerge on the list.

The fallacy of the rating, comments, or other user-contributed measures as indicators for interestingness is that it can be gamed. Users will try to “break the algorithm” for the purpose of self-promotion.

The most popular thing is not necessarily the best thing. The most views or most votes doesn’t always win.

Page 1 of 1